NBAF: The Land - Grady Thrasher, Letter to The Flagpole

Wed, 08/27/2008 - 12:11pm
Submitted by matt

Pete, your beautifully written editorial [Pub Notes, Aug. 20], insightful if not inciteful, is greatly appreciated by more people in the Athens community than you might imagine, given the Banner-Herald’s propensity to minimize or even trivialize the NBAF opponents’ numbers and points of view.

I do wish to contest two points that the NBAF proponents like to emphasize, but which are not immutable truths. Points even in your wise commentary you seem to overlook or concede.

First, regardless of whether there is any valid reason for Athens to host the NBAF, there is no valid argument for something so large, environmentally degrading and potentially dangerous to be placed on the South Milledge Avenue site that was so carelessly offered DHS by UGA. We have asked, “Why this site, of all the land owned by UGA?” The answers, in all iterations, boil down to “convenience.”

“Convenience!” A sad commentary on UGA’s stewardship of the vast amount of land it controls and UGA’s apparent absence of care for community aesthetics as well as the environment.

Second, the reasoning that “UGA will eventually build out that land, NBAF or not” is nothing more than a self-serving argument initiated by NBAF proponents themselves to emphasize the futility of any effort to preserve the “unique and distinctive” (a term of art defined in the DEIS) character of the South Milledge acreage. The proposed site, particularly when considered with the State Botanical Garden, Whitehall Forest, the equestrian center, the river, and, now, the outdoor playing fields being developed by UGA across the street, is an integral part of what has evolved into a premier outdoor recreational and scenic area for our community. UGA is not compelled to “build out” that unique and irreplaceable landscape. Maybe farsighted people within the community and within UGA will now take positive action to pursue the commendable goal of preserving that acreage for the appreciation and enjoyment of present and future generations. By doing so, UGA could quickly change its current image from community bully to community hero.